Medicare and Medicaid · Sarasota County
Sunnyside Nursing Home
5201 BAHIA VISTA STREET, Sarasota, FL 34232 · 9413712729
Overall rating
5/5
Sunnyside Nursing Home is a non-profit nursing home in Sarasota, FL with 60 licensed beds. CMS rates it 5 out of 5 stars overall — above average for Florida nursing homes. Subcategory scores: staffing (5/5), health inspections (4/5), quality measures (5/5).
Are you the owner or manager of this facility?
Claim your profile to respond to families, update your listing, and unlock featured placement.
How this home is rated
CMS data last updated May 1, 2026
About this home
- Capacity
- 60 beds
- Ownership
- Non profit - Church related
- Type
- Medicare and Medicaid
- County
- Sarasota
What the Ratings Mean
Sunnyside Nursing Home earns an overall 5-star rating from CMS, which is the highest possible score and puts it well above average compared to nursing homes nationwide. That overall rating is built from three separate scores, each measuring something different about the facility. The health inspection rating comes in at 4 stars, meaning state inspectors found fewer and less serious issues than most nursing homes - not a perfect record, but clearly above average and nothing that should raise red flags for families. Staffing and quality measures both hit the full 5 stars, which are arguably the two ratings families should pay the closest attention to.
A 5-star staffing score means nurses and aides are spending significantly more time with each resident than you'd typically see elsewhere - in practical terms, that means call lights get answered, residents get help with meals and mobility, and staff aren't stretched so thin that care starts to slip. The 5-star quality measures score reflects how residents are actually doing physically and clinically - things like whether residents are developing pressure sores, losing mobility, or experiencing falls. Across all 15 of those health outcome measures, Sunnyside is performing at the top of the scale. Taken together, these ratings paint a genuinely strong picture of a well-staffed facility where residents tend to fare well.
Staffing at a Glance
Sunnyside Nursing Home staffs notably higher than most Florida nursing homes, which is worth understanding in practical terms. Residents here receive an average of 5.40 total nurse hours per day, compared to the Florida average of 3.87 - that's roughly an hour and a half more hands-on care each day. Even more striking is the registered nurse coverage: 1.17 RN hours per resident daily versus the state average of just 0.52. In real life, that difference can mean a more experienced nurse is available to catch early warning signs, manage medications, or respond to concerns rather than leaving those tasks stretched thin across a large number of residents. More hours don't guarantee perfect care, but they do suggest that on a typical day, residents at Sunnyside are less likely to wait long for attention and more likely to have a qualified nurse nearby when something comes up.
Inspection & Penalty History
Sunnyside Nursing Home has a solid inspection track record that should give families reasonable confidence. With a 4 out of 5 star health inspection rating and no government penalties or fines on record, this facility hasn't raised the kind of red flags that would warrant serious concern. That doesn't mean a facility is perfect - inspections only capture a snapshot in time - but a clean penalty history combined with an above-average inspection rating is genuinely a good sign when you're weighing your options. You can compare this facility's record against others in Sarasota on the Sarasota nursing homes and assisted living page.
Questions to Ask When You Visit
- How many residents does each certified nursing assistant care for during a typical day shift, and how does that change at night and on weekends?
- How long have your charge nurses and CNAs been working here, and what does your staff turnover look like over the past year?
- If my loved one falls or has a medical emergency overnight, walk me through exactly what happens - who responds, how fast, and how does the family get notified?
- Can residents choose when they wake up, when they eat, and how they spend their afternoons, or does the facility run on a fixed schedule that everyone follows?
- What happens when a resident reports that they're in pain or asks for help with something - who do they tell, and how long does it typically take before someone addresses it?
- Has this facility been cited for any deficiencies in the last two state inspections, and can you show me the most recent inspection report?
For more guidance on evaluating facilities, see our guide to questions to ask when choosing a Florida nursing home.
Not sure yet?
Talk to someone who can help
You don't have to figure this out alone. A placement specialist will reach out to walk you through your options — at no cost, no pressure.
