Florida Eldercare Hub

Medicare and Medicaid · Sarasota County

Benderson Family Skilled Nursing And Rehab Center

1959 N HONORE AVE, Sarasota, FL 34235 · 9413793553

Overall rating

5/5

Benderson Family Skilled Nursing And Rehab Center is a for-profit nursing home in Sarasota, FL with 45 licensed beds. CMS rates it 5 out of 5 stars overall — above average for Florida nursing homes. Subcategory scores: staffing (5/5), health inspections (5/5), quality measures (4/5).

Are you the owner or manager of this facility?

Claim your profile to respond to families, update your listing, and unlock featured placement.

Claim This Profile →
Benderson Family Skilled Nursing And Rehab Center exterior
Benderson Family Skilled Nursing And Rehab Center exterior

How this home is rated

Health Inspection5/5
Staffing5/5
Quality Measures4/5

CMS data last updated May 1, 2026

About this home

Capacity
45 beds
Ownership
For profit - Corporation
Type
Medicare and Medicaid
County
Sarasota
What the Ratings Mean

Benderson Family Skilled Nursing And Rehab Center holds an overall 5-star rating from CMS - the highest possible - which is a composite of three separate scores that each look at a different piece of what daily life and care look like inside a facility. The health inspection rating is a perfect 5 stars, meaning state inspectors found very few, if any, serious problems during their visits. That's a strong sign that the facility is being run carefully and that residents aren't being put at risk through neglect or poor practices. The staffing rating is also 5 stars, which means nurses and aides are spending significantly more time with each resident than you'd typically see elsewhere. In practical terms, that translates to call lights getting answered, residents being turned and repositioned to prevent bedsores, and staff having enough bandwidth to actually know their residents.

The quality measures rating comes in at 4 stars - above average, though not perfect. This score is drawn from 15 clinical indicators, things like how often residents develop infections, experience falls, lose too much weight, or need to be hospitalized. A 4 here is genuinely good and means outcomes for residents are better than most facilities, even if there's a small margin of room to improve. Taken together, these three scores paint a picture of a facility that's well-staffed, well-managed, and delivering strong results for the people in its care - which is about as reassuring a combination as a family can find when weighing options.

Staffing at a Glance

Staffing levels at Benderson Family Skilled Nursing And Rehab Center come in above what you'd typically see across Florida nursing homes, which is worth noting when you're trying to picture what daily care actually looks like for a resident. On an average day, each resident here receives about 4.66 total nurse hours of attention, compared to the Florida average of 3.87 - that gap can translate to staff having a little more time to help with meals, respond to call lights, or just check in without feeling rushed. The registered nurse numbers are also higher, at 0.74 hours per resident per day versus the state average of 0.52, meaning more of that care time comes from higher-credentialed nurses who can catch changes in a resident's condition earlier. None of this guarantees a perfect experience, but more nursing hours generally means residents are less likely to wait long for help and more likely to have someone notice when something seems off.

Inspection & Penalty History

Benderson Family Skilled Nursing And Rehab Center has a strong inspection track record - it holds a 5-out-of-5-star health inspection rating from the government, and there are no penalties or fines on record at all. For families doing their research, that's genuinely reassuring. It means inspectors haven't found the kinds of serious or repeated problems that trigger financial penalties, and the facility has consistently met care standards over time. While no rating tells the whole story, a clean penalty history combined with a top inspection score is a good sign that this is a facility that takes compliance and care quality seriously. You can compare this facility's record against others in Sarasota on the Sarasota nursing homes and assisted living page.

Questions to Ask When You Visit
  1. How many residents does each certified nursing assistant care for during the day shift, and how does that change at night and on weekends?
  2. How long have your charge nurses and CNAs been working here on average, and what does your staff turnover look like over the past year?
  3. If my loved one had a fall or a sudden change in condition overnight, walk me through exactly what happens - who gets called, in what order, and how quickly?
  4. What does a typical Tuesday look like for a resident who doesn't have therapy scheduled — how do they spend their morning, afternoon, and evening?
  5. Can you show me the most recent state inspection report, and can you explain what was cited and what's been done to fix it?
  6. If my family member isn't eating well or seems withdrawn, how would your team catch that, and who would reach out to us and when?

For more guidance on evaluating facilities, see our guide to questions to ask when choosing a Florida nursing home.

Not sure yet?

Talk to someone who can help

You don't have to figure this out alone. A placement specialist will reach out to walk you through your options — at no cost, no pressure.

Facility you're asking about

Benderson Family Skilled Nursing And Rehab Center

Only your name and phone are required — fill in the rest if you have it.

We may pass your details to a trusted placement specialist who can help. You decide who you talk to and when — no pressure.